AI versus Marshy - What Do You Mean AI Can't Copy Everything?

I’ve been experimenting with AI tools like ChatGPT and Midjourney, and I’ve been thinking a lot about the implications of AI-generated content on copyright laws. As I explore the possibilities of these tools, I’ve come across some interesting questions about what it means for AI to ‘copy’ content. In this article, I want to dive into one of these questions: what does it mean for AI to ‘copy’ everything? The law exists to contest ideas in an adversarial system for the betterment of society. It has many faults - but arguing for copyright isn’t one of them. I’m not sure how this gets solved and it’s above my pay grade - I do like how Europe in particular stands up for this stuff. They led the world into implementing GDPR protections, and Mistral is an incumbent from Europe seeking to position itself as an alternative model for Generative AI - their strategic memo is a gripping read on why they’re doing this. – I’ve been playing with ChatGPT (Dall-E) for image generation and combining it with Midjourney. Here’s a photo of my work set up: Where I work when we’re not having a power outage - looking at you Melbourne Summer rain. I ask ChatGPT to describe it as if it’s being drawn by someone through text description alone, and then give the prompt to Midjourney: Imagine you’re drawing a workspace that is designed for productivity and personal comfort, radiating a sense of modern technology blended with personal touches. ​ Begin with a wide desk situated in front of a large window that offers a view of lush green foliage. The window is framed by two visible bamboo roll-up blinds, adding a natural element to the scene. On the desk, place a dual-monitor setup. The left monitor displays the desktop icons while the right monitor showcases a wallpaper of two smiling people, suggesting a personal connection to the user. ​ To the left of the monitors, set a ring light on a sleek, adjustable tripod, indicating readiness for video conferencing or content creation. There’s also a webcam perched on top of the left monitor. ​ In the center of the desk, sketch a closed laptop perched on a thin stand, indicating a preference for ergonomics. Rest atop the laptop a black notebook and a pair of black-rimmed glasses, hinting at work breaks or moments of reflection. ​ Directly in front of where the user would sit, draw a white wireless keyboard, its minimalistic design suggesting modernity and simplicity. Next to it, portray a black, ergonomically-shaped mouse resting on a large, green gaming mouse pad with an artistic, possibly serpentine design. ​ On the right side of the desk, include a personal touch with a small, framed photograph featuring three people in sports attire, all smiling, adding a warm, familial atmosphere to the workspace. ​ Finally, add a cat tree beside the desk, complete with platforms and resting areas, implying the companionship of a pet within the space. This pet accessory also softens the tech-heavy vibe, introducing a sense of home and comfort. ​ Overall, ensure that the drawing communicates a balance between a high-tech work environment and a space that is personal and lived-in, reflecting the character and interests of its occupant. Here’s what it churns out: Originally appeared in newsletter : AI versus Marshy #29: voice-activated ChatGPT, brain machines, and is it right to copy?